Overview
Fake landlords are one of the biggest blind spots in tenant screening.
Applicants who know they have poor rental history — or are currently being evicted — often create a fake landlord identity to hide the truth.
This guide shows multifamily operators how fake landlords operate, the red flags to watch for, and how to validate landlords before trusting any rental history data.
Why Fake Landlords Are a Growing Problem
Fake landlord references are rising for several reasons:
- It’s easy to buy VoIP numbers
- Email addresses can be created in seconds
- Applicants can coach friends to respond
- Rental histories are rarely cross-checked
- Many property managers skip verification due to time constraints
This makes fake landlord references the #1 way bad renters bypass tenant screening — and the leading cause of:
- Bad debt
- Evictions
- Skip-outs
- High-risk residents
- NOI damage
How Fake Landlord Schemes Typically Work
Most fake landlord attempts fall into a few common patterns:
1. Applicant lists a friend/family member as “previous landlord”
This is the most common type.
The “landlord” gives glowing reviews no matter what the applicant’s true history is.
2. Applicant creates a fake phone number or email
Common signs:
- VoIP number
- No online trace
- Free Gmail/Yahoo email
- No business domain
- No digital footprint
3. Applicant claims to rent from an LLC created recently
Often the LLC:
- Was formed only days or weeks ago
- Has no rental units
- Has a virtual mailbox or apartment address
- Has no website or business listing
4. Fake landlords who can’t answer basic questions
When contacted, they:
- Provide vague answers
- Don’t know rent amount or lease dates
- Over-exaggerate applicant’s “great behavior”
- Sound coached
- Avoid verification questions
Red Flags That Indicate a Potential Fake Landlord
Here are the most reliable signals that a landlord may be fake:
Contact Information Red Flags
- Phone number used for unrelated businesses
- VoIP number with no history
- Email from a free domain (Gmail, Yahoo, Hotmail)
- Email with spelling errors or mismatched names
Identity Red Flags
- Landlord name does NOT match public ownership records
- No property management company exists
- No online presence
- Recent LLC formation
Behavioral Red Flags
- Landlord responds instantly to everything
- Landlord refuses to share ownership proof
- Landlord gives extremely positive feedback
- Landlord avoids direct questions
Document Red Flags
- Ledger looks edited or manually typed
- Ledger has inconsistent formatting
- Ledger dates appear copy/pasted
- No official PM software layout (Yardi/AppFolio/Buildium)
How to Validate a Landlord (Quick Checklist)
Before accepting any rental history, verify:
✔ 1. Does this person actually own or manage the property?
Check county property records, business listings, Google Maps, PM websites.
✔ 2. Does the phone number/email belong to a real landlord?
Look for reputation history, domain legitimacy, call patterns.
✔ 3. Does the story match the applicant’s documents?
Lease, ledger, dates, addresses, and payment history must align.
✔ 4. Does the landlord have a digital footprint?
No trace = high risk.
✔ 5. Do responses sound too perfect?
Fraudsters often give flawless feedback to avoid scrutiny.
How Renter, Inc. Removes Fake Landlords from the Screening Process
Renter, Inc. uses:
- Automated property ownership checks
- Business registration validation
- Email & phone identity scoring
- Fraud pattern detection
- Manual analyst review
- Secure tenant-portal verification
This eliminates fake landlords before they ever provide a reference — helping operators prevent evictions and NOI loss.
Takeaways
- Fake landlords are common and increasingly sophisticated
- Most tenant screening systems do NOT detect fake landlord references
- Proper landlord validation dramatically reduces bad renter approvals
- Renter, Inc. offers the most reliable landlord identity verification for VOR/RHV
Want to eliminate fake landlord references?
Book a call to see how Renter, Inc. strengthens your Verification of Rent workflow.
Leave a Reply